Nedumpara

If the right to vote is not a fundamental right, we cannot call ourselves a democracy. The right to vote ought to be made a fundamental right, especially when even the right to walk on a footpath has been declared a fundamental right by the Supreme Court.

The right to vote and to participate in elections is a valuable legal right. I am not comfortable calling it a fundamental right, as treating it as such has created numerous problems. In fact, the Constitution has created more problems in this regard than it has resolved. Anyone whose rights are infringed must certainly have access to a legal forum. Furthermore, when a whole group of people is affected, any legal action must take the form of representative proceedings, for which the Code of Civil Procedure explicitly provides.
Why assume that an ordinary civil court cannot deliver justice? In ordinary civil courts, representative proceedings provide structured forums for review, correction, and appeal. Conversely, when you go directly to the Supreme Court and it rules contrary to what is just and right, what would you do? You file endless petitions—challenging the SIR, demanding the suspension of the Election Commissioner, and so on. All are dismissed. What would you do?
In light of the allegations against him, an Election Commissioner ought to be like Caesar’s wife—above suspicion—and should resign gracefully. Elections are sacrosanct, and the Election Commission must remain beyond question. The paper ballot should be restored.
Regarding the appointment process for the Election Commission, the decision should ideally be made through mutual agreement between the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition. If they cannot agree on a candidate, a third neutral person should be co-opted by both leaders. If they still fail to agree on a third person, an alternative fallback is necessary. I suggested the Vice President because he is a high constitutional authority deserving of respect. While critics argue that Presidents and Vice Presidents act as mere rubber stamps for the Prime Minister who nominated them, history shows exceptions—such as when President Giani Zail Singh considered dismissing Indira Gandhi’s government. Indira Gandhi only appointed Zail Singh!
Under no circumstances should the Chief Justice or any member of the judiciary be involved in appointing the Election Commission. A judge’s job is solely to adjudicate cases; judges must stay far removed from governance. When judges attempt to usurp executive authority through Public Interest Litigations (PILs), it undermines governance. These are dangerous shortcuts. Vesting judges with unaccountable legislative and executive power will not save democracy—it will only lead to judicial corruption.
Judges used to be humble. When I entered the Kerala High Court in 1979 as a litigant, judges received no lavish perks or official cars; they drove themselves and earned a modest salary of 3,500 rupees. They were judges, not kings. Today, every judge acts like a king. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. When judges assume executive and legislative duties while remaining accountable to no one, corruption follows.
Once judges become corrupt, the executive can collect dossiers on their misdeeds—such as undisclosed properties in London or Dubai—giving the government leverage over the judiciary. We must return to fundamental principles. PILs have destroyed the judicial institution. Despite widespread enthusiasm from the press and the public, who view PILs as a cure-all, PILs lack a sound jurisprudential foundation. A PIL asks a court to issue rulings affecting millions without proper representative proceedings. Having two judges and a handful of lawyers decide the nation’s fate behind their backs is fundamentally unconstitutional and undemocratic.

Stay Informed with Legal Insights

Get the latest legal news, case studies, and jurisdiction updates delivered to your preferred channel