Nedumpara

I have repeatedly stated in court, as well as on social media, that the dismissal of a writ petition—or the dismissal of writ petitions after writ petitions (sometimes with costs of ₹5 lakhs, as Justice Manu of the Kerala High Court ordered in one case)—at least in SARFAESI proceedings, will not bar a fresh writ petition based on a fresh cause of action.​Many lawyers and MSME borrowers ask in disbelief how that is possible. My answer is:

If an issue has been decided in earlier proceedings—namely, whether an MSME petitioner is entitled to the protection of the notification dated 29.05.2015—and has been decided against him, then that decision leads to issue estoppel. Thereafter, if he institutes a fresh writ petition upon the issuance of a new auction notice or another new cause […]

If the right to vote is not a fundamental right, we cannot call ourselves a democracy. The right to vote ought to be made a fundamental right, especially when even the right to walk on a footpath has been declared a fundamental right by the Supreme Court.

The right to vote and to participate in elections is a valuable legal right. I am not comfortable calling it a fundamental right, as treating it as such has created numerous problems. In fact, the Constitution has created more problems in this regard than it has resolved. Anyone whose rights are infringed must certainly have […]