Nedumpara

I have repeatedly stated in court, as well as on social media, that the dismissal of a writ petition—or the dismissal of writ petitions after writ petitions (sometimes with costs of ₹5 lakhs, as Justice Manu of the Kerala High Court ordered in one case)—at least in SARFAESI proceedings, will not bar a fresh writ petition based on a fresh cause of action.​Many lawyers and MSME borrowers ask in disbelief how that is possible. My answer is:

If an issue has been decided in earlier proceedings—namely, whether an MSME petitioner is entitled to the protection of the notification dated 29.05.2015—and has been decided against him, then that decision leads to issue estoppel. Thereafter, if he institutes a fresh writ petition upon the issuance of a new auction notice or another new cause of action and pleads protection under the MSMED Act and the notification, the bank is certainly entitled to raise the contention that the benefit of the notification cannot be raised again because it was already decided in the earlier proceedings—even though the cause of action or the lis continues due to the new cause of action. The reason is that an earlier decision between the parties on an issue that is the subject matter of a fresh proceeding constitutes issue estoppel. It cannot be raised again; it is an absolute bar.

However, prior to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Pro Knits—that is, before August 1, 2024—except in the cases in which I appeared for the MSMEs, probably no MSME ever claimed protection under the MSMED Act and the notification. Therefore, there was no question of protection under the notification ever having been decided in any case prior to 1.8.2024, except in those cases in which I appeared. Consequently, there is no “issue estoppel” in cases where MSMEs claim benefits under the notification subsequent to the Supreme Court’s judgment in Pro Knits.

In many cases, an objection was raised by the respondent bank that the borrower had invoked the jurisdiction of the High Court against the SARFAESI action on many previous occasions—in some cases as many as seven or eight times—and on none of those occasions was the plea for protection under the notification ever sought and therefore the borrower is estopped from claiming the benefit of the notification.
The argument that the MSME borrower had failed to raise the protection under the notification which they could and should have raised earlier, and are therefore barred by the doctrine of constructive res judicata, has no foundation in law. The reason is simple: the earlier failure to raise an objection or make a claim under the MSMED Act and notification cannot be treated as ‘constructive res judicata’ because the lis has not come to an end. If the lis had come to an end, the reopening of the earlier decision could not be sought, and denying the benefit of the notification would be possible under the doctrine of constructive res judicata.
For the doctrine of constructive res judicata to apply, there must first be res judicata; if there is no res judicata, there is no constructive res judicata. For res judicata to apply, there must be finality—there must be a termination of the lis and an adjudication on the merits either actual or constructive, meaning nothing remains thereafter and no new cause of action arises. If a new cause of action arises and the lis is continuing with no end to it, then a party who previously failed to raise the plea of protection under the MSMED Act can raise it again because there is no bar of res judicata. Constructive res judicata only bars a party when an issue could and should have been claimed and the lis has come to an end. Where there is no res judicata, there is no constructive res judicata. With the issuance of a fresh auction notice or any other SARFAESI action, there is fresh litigation. In this fresh litigation, the claim under the MSMED Act can be raised because there is no issue estoppel—in the earlier proceedings, the claim under the notification dated 29.05.2015 was never raised or decided.
Somebody might ask whether this will not lead to an abuse of the process of law. An abuse of the process of law occurs when you do not have a right—when you are barred by res judicata, constructive res judicata, or issue estoppel, and still attempt to litigate. The law exists to do justice, and the MSMEs are entitled to the benefit of a notification that was unjustly denied to them.

The High Courts, including the Kerala High Court, have denied the benefit of the notification to hundreds of MSMEs on the erroneous premise that their failure to claim the benefit during the earlier writ proceedings amounted to constructive res judicata.

As a senior member of the Bar, and for one to whom law and jurisprudence are a passion, it would be my pleasure and privilege to answer any question on jurisprudence or on any subject. I say so with all humility and in the unstinted faith that I will not be misunderstood.

Stay Informed with Legal Insights

Get the latest legal news, case studies, and jurisdiction updates delivered to your preferred channel