Should the lawyer who told the Chief Justice, “You don’t deserve to be in the chair,” be punished for contempt, or not?Whatever I write, I write with a great amount of pain and anguish. I am someone who has spent four and a half decades in the legal profession. Every passing day brings great pain as I see how things have degraded.Yesterday, an incident happened where a lawyer used abusive words against the Chief Justice, Chief Justice Surya Kant. He said, “You don’t deserve to be in the chair.”What he said is certainly not acceptable, and no Chief Justice can tolerate it. So, the SCBA has, I believe, filed a contempt of court case against the lawyer. This lawyer, I believe, may be convicted for contempt, or Justice Surya Kant may take a lenient view, as Justice Gavai did.The question is: can we contain the anger and frustration of litigants and lawyers through contempt of court proceedings? And how many contempt of court proceedings will you initiate?Now, see, the judges fail to realize that the moment you enter the domain of the executive—the moment you started governing the country through PILs, acting in substitution of the executive and the legislature—you usurped their power. Then you became not a democracy, but a “judge-ocracy.” People have even coined a new term: “milordocracy.”Judges cannot solve all the problems. There is an elected executive. They may be a total failure, but you cannot substitute them. And if you try to substitute them, then the people will treat you like they treat politicians. They abuse the Prime Minister, and that freedom ought to be there in a democracy.The common man may not use the most appropriate language. He may not be balanced in his approach. That is a liberty you have to concede to the common people. They have the right to protest. Protests sometimes lead to violence as well.Somebody in the political arena is seasoned to it, or ought to be mentally prepared for it. You cannot enjoy power while remaining in glass houses; people will throw stones at you. Confining yourselves to your legitimate domain of the adjudication of lis is the answer to the increasing abuse you face. I respect the institution; judges come and go. No democracy and no society can survive without a judiciary. So, what the judges ought to realize is that they cannot govern the country. People may come to you bringing PILs asking you to remove the Prime Minister, remove the Election Commissioner, or enact laws. But simply put, that is not your job.I only pray to the Almighty that the judges do not fall prey to the folly and great damage to the country that a few lawyers commit by bringing PILs asking the court to decide and govern everything under the sun.
The Tata Disputes: What the mainstream media won’t tell you—the truth I am sharing here.
I am telling certain truths about the Tata Trusts and Tata Sons because there is nobody else to say it. There are no newspapers and no media to tell the truth.The two important trusts are the Sir Ratan Tata Trust, which was created in 1919, and the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust. Sir Ratan Tata had […]
My Philosophy as a LawyerMathews J Nedumpara
Solutions to all difficult problems ought to be simple. All that we need is an innovative mind—here, as a lawyer, an innovative legal mind.The means are as important as the end, so the means must be compatible with the end and must not be unduly vitiated. The means we adopt ought to be—and certainly are—moral, […]
Why do I love Papinian more than any other jurist who has ever lived on Earth?
I am both hated and loved for the Latin maxims I often use in court. I am a great fan of classical Roman law. Many lawyers may not know that all of our law originated in Rome.You have likely heard of the Middle Ages, or the Dark Ages. Before the Dark Ages, there was a […]
If elected as President of the Kerala High Court Bar Association, I will demand the notification of vacancies, the invitation of applications, and the scrutiny of those applications. I will ensure that no name is recommended by the Collegium without consulting the Bar, and that nothing is done—or allowed to be done—in an opaque and secretive manner.
Three-fourths, if not four-fifths, of the judges of the Supreme Court, Chief Justices of the High Courts, and judges who constitute the Collegium of the Supreme Court and High Courts are the kith and kin of former judges, senior lawyers, Chief Ministers, and Governors—and nobody else.The Collegium is a synonym for nepotism and favoritism. It […]
The abolition of the draconian law of contempt—and particularly contempt of court by scandalization—is the greatest tribute we, the citizens of this country, can pay to the great soul of Justice Kannan, who expired today and who fought against corruption and for transparency in the judiciary
Justice Karnan is no more. He suffered a massive heart attack this morning, and his funeral will be held tomorrow at 11:00 AM at his native place.As his friend and lawyer, I am deeply shocked by this sad news. Justice Karnan’s conviction for contempt of court—for scandalizing the court by raising allegations of corruption against […]
Could there be anything more absurd than the fact that, while judges of subordinate courts can be held guilty of contempt of their own courts, judges of the High Court and Supreme Court cannot?
If a judge of a subordinate court can be held liable for contempt of their own court, the same principle should apply to a judge of the High Court and the Supreme Court. If a High Court judge acts contemptuously and commits contempt of their own court, then, like a subordinate court judge, they should […]
The Kerala High Court dismissed a writ petition instituted by Mr. Nedumpara seeking a declaration that the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971—and in particular Sections 2(c)(i), 14, 16, and 17(5) thereof, which provide for contempt of court by scandalization and require a person accused of contempt to incriminate himself by filing an affidavit in proof of his innocence or defense—is unconstitutional, and further seeking a declaration that if the law of contempt is held constitutional, there can be no distinction between a judge of the HC/SC and a judge of a subordinate court, and that both are equally liable for contempt of their own court in the event they commit such contempt.Read the Petition.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA IN ITS EXTRA-ORDINARY ORIGINAL JURISDICTION W. P.(C) NO. 14564OF 2016 Mathews J. Nedumpara … Petitioner Union of India & Ors. … Respondents MEMORANDUM OF WRIT PETITION FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA. Counsel for the Petitioner P.BIJIMON (B-732) (K/3173/1999)JACOB SAMUEL (J-1316) (K/259/1997Room No.210, 2nd Floor,Prasanna Vihar […]
Why I Say It Is Impossible for an MSME Borrower to Lose His Case: Read This Article, and You Will Have the Answer.
Mathews J. Nedumpara9820535428
My Political Philosophy
Many might wonder why, in one of my earlier articles, in which I referred to rumours circulating in Delhi alleging that the cash discovered following the fire at Justice Yashwant Varma’s residence belonged to former Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, I also wrote about my ancestry—something that might appear entirely out of place in an article […]