Nedumpara

Why do I love Papinian more than any other jurist who has ever lived on Earth?

I am both hated and loved for the Latin maxims I often use in court. I am a great fan of classical Roman law. Many lawyers may not know that all of our law originated in Rome.
​You have likely heard of the Middle Ages, or the Dark Ages. Before the Dark Ages, there was a period known as the classical Greco-Roman era, which was a golden era. That golden era was when the five great jurists lived: Papinian, Ulpian, Modestinus, Gaius, and Paulus.
​A large number of Latin maxims are attributed to Papinian. You must have heard of Justinian’s Digest. The Digest mostly consists of the writings of Julian, Gaius, Paulus, Ulpian, and Modestinus, though not as much from Papinian.
​Papinian is credited for his Latin maxims, which were austere, dense, and exact. He was capable of distilling a complex rule into a single, unforgettable sentence without wasting words. How beautiful and meaningful those Latin maxims are!
​There is a great story about Papinian, who was such a great man.
​Papinian was the Praetorian Prefect under Emperor Septimius Severus, and Severus’s son, Caracalla, executed him—along with Papinian’s own son. What was the crime Papinian committed? He was a role model of a judge, the greatest judge humanity has ever seen.
​The emperor had two sons, Caracalla and Geta, who were quarreling. Papinian was assigned the job of bringing peace between them. After Septimius Severus’s death, Caracalla, the elder son, called his younger brother, Geta, to their mother’s apartment and killed him there.
​Caracalla then wanted Papinian to justify this fratricide, which Papinian refused to do. Consequently, Caracalla dismissed Papinian from his office as principal judge and demanded that the great jurist use his prestige and legal skill to compose a formal speech to the Roman Senate, justifying Geta’s assassination as an act of self-defense.
​Papinian refused with his famous rebuke: “It is not so easy to justify a parricide—the murder of a close relative—as it is to commit it.” He then added that accusing an innocent victim after murdering him amounted to a second murder.
​In AD 212, Caracalla ordered Papinian’s execution by beheading with an axe. Papinian’s martyrdom alongside his son—for the rule of law and for justice—made him the greatest symbol of judicial integrity.

Stay Informed with Legal Insights

Get the latest legal news, case studies, and jurisdiction updates delivered to your preferred channel