26 February

Sticky

Is it true that our legal system is founded on the premise that no court can do justice? (Read the arguments notes by Shri Nedumpara in challenge of Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act)

Brevity is the soul of wit, said Shakespeare. I would therefore like to keep the instant argument note as brief as possible. I do so for more than one reason.It is a travesty of justice that today in the 21st century when even jurisdictions other than civil law and common law countries have accepted the observance of the principles of natural justice fundamental, we in India increasingly trample the very first principles.The Petitioners, MSMEs were constrained to seek a declaration at the hands of this court that Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act which empower the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate/ District...

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Demolition of Maradu homes, who will tell the court that it went wrong?

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

I pen these few lines with great amount of pain and anguish. The Government of Kerala, in furtherance of an all party meeting convened by Shri Pinarayi Vijayan, Chief Minister of Kerala, engaged Shri Harish Salve, probably the highest paid lawyer in the country, to save 450 odd families of their homes, which were ordered to be demolished by a Bench of the Supreme Court headed by Hon'ble Shri Justice Arun Misra. The background of the case is fairly known to all. Stated in brief, the Supreme Court, in complete violation of the procedure contemplated under the...

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

“If the King was not above law, but under God and the law, the Master of the roster, the Chief Justice too is not above the law”

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

A Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court dismissed with a cost of Rs. 20,000/- a petition by one Arun Misra as a 'party – in – person’ seeking a direction that certain Writ Petitions instituted by him shall not be listed before a particular judge. The order of the court is cryptic and it does not state what exactly is the factual matrix. All that is discernible from the order is that the petitioner had sought a direction to the Registry of the Court not to list cases filed by him before a “Particular Judge”. The order merely says that...

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

There is no way to salvage our legal system unless and until we abandon the current practice of treating res judicata as precedent

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

15.7.2021 There is no way to salvage our legal system unless and until we abandon the current practice of treating res judicata as precedent In this country, the distinction between the concept of res judicata and precedent is largely forgotten. As a result, a judgment of a superior court in a case between A and B, which may be erroneous but binding on the said parties, becomes binding on C and D, nay, on posterity as the law of the land. Often it is misconceived that every word of a judgment of a superior court is binding, the law of the land....

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Press Release issued in furtherance of the Press Conference held at the Chandigarh Press Club today at 12pm

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

Demolition at Aravali In the PIL (Writ Petition no. 562 of 2021) instituted by 5 slumdwellers the Supreme Court ordered demolition of the shanties of the thousands of slumdwellers and to report compliance thereof within 6 weeks, and posted the case for reporting compliance on 27.7.2021. The order of the Supreme Court was one rendered void ab initio for the following reasons: a) in a Petition filed by merely 5 slumdwellers, at the best the court could have rejected the same, even with costs, but the Court had no jurisdiction to order demolition of the shanties of thousands of poor who were...

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Letter to the CJ of Bombay High Court- My Lords hear the slumdwellers before your Lordships order their eviction

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

7.7.2021 Hon'ble Mr. Justice Dipankar Datta,Chief Justice of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay May it please your Lordship Sub: Hearing of suo motu PIL- demolition of the shanties of slumdwellers- without there being a single slumdweller on the party array or any kind of representation on their behalf. What I came to notice from picking up today's newspaper is a report titled is "Is Government land executive's paternal property: CJ". The report by Times of India correspondent Rosy Sequeira goes on to say that the Hon'ble the Chief Justice criticized the policy of the successive governments in granting protection to the slumdwellers....

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Denial of bail to Fr. Stan Swamy-a dark event in India’s history

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

The denial of bail to Father Stan Swamy which has led to his incarceration and eventual death in a private hospital in Bombay still under judicial custody is one of the darkest incidents of denial of the fundamental freedom of life and liberty enshrined in our constitution. Even during the medieval days, the custody of a person accused was permissible only if the offences committed were so grave and such that if the person was at large he would not be available for trial and to undergo the punishment. Blackstone in his Commentaries of Laws of England has stated this...

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Nedumpara’s Letter to CJI seeking Justice for the slumdwellers of Aravali Hills

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

To Hon'ble Mr. Justice NV Ramana,Chief Justice of India,Also to,Hon'ble Mr. Manohar Lal Khattar,Chief Minister of Haryana Sub: Demolition of the shanties of thousands of migrant laborers and urban poor, in the implementation of a judgement of the Supreme Court in purported PILs, rendered entirely behind their back. I have been on a campaign since 2010, when I first came to Bombay as a stranger, after being in the Bar for more than 25 years. It may appear strange to your Lordship, the campaign I started was for the "cry of the poor" to borrow an expression from Justice Krishna Iyer, to save...

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Jacobite Church case- Synopsis

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

Jacobite Church case- Synopsis The Petitioners are constrained to file this review, sadly, only because this Honble court, the Petitioners beg to submit with all humility and with utmost respect, failed to record the core of their contention that the instant church in question, and for that matter not a single out of the 1064 churches of the Malankara Syrian Jacobite Church, was a party to the Samudayan case which has culminated in the judgement of the 5-judge constitution bench of the Supreme Court, namely, AIR 1959 SC 31 and, therefore, the said judgement is not binding on the Petitioner church...

26 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Video recording the court proceedings, an Offence?

Posted by Mathews J Nedumpara

in Blogs/Articles

Video recording the court proceedings, an Offence? Mathews J. Nedumpara.19th September 2019 Nullum crimen sine lege, nulla poena sine lege is a Latin maxim that means "no crime or punishment without a law." There can be no crime committed, and no punishment meted out, without a violation of penal law as it existed at the time. This basic legal principle has been incorporated into international criminal law. This is also one of the fundamental principles of law which is incorporated in Part III of the Constitution. In simple words, no person can be proceeded against and punished unless the legislature had...

Disclaimer: