Plea in the Bombay High Court by NLC seeking notification of the vacancies of the judges and an open and transparent selection of the most eligible and deserving.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO.      OF 2018 In the matter of Article 226 of the Constitution of India; AND In the matter of Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India; AND In the matter of Articles 124 and 217 of the Constitution of India. AND In the matter of appointment of Judges to the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature at Bombay. 1.        Rohini M. Amin, Advocate and General Secretary of National Lawyers’ Campaign for Judicial Transparency and Reforms, adult, Indian inhabitant, having her address at             304, Hari Chambers, 3rd Floor,             54/68  SBS Marg,             Near Old Custom House, Fort,             Mumbai- 400 023. 2....

Continue reading

S.3 of the judges Protection Act which provides for absolute immunity to judges from civil and criminal action even when they willfully deny justice is unconstitutional, pleads Sabina Lakdawala. Read her Petition

S.3 of the judges Protection Act which provides for absolute immunity to judges from civil and criminal action even when they willfully deny justice is unconstitutional, pleads Sabina Lakdawala. Read her Petition Mathews J Nedumpara 26.02.2023IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE IN BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVL JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. ……………… OF 2022. Sabina Lakdawala       …Petitioners Versus Komal Singh Rajput & Ors.    …Respondents I N D E X Sr. No.      Particulars       Page No. 1.         Proforma         I-III 2.         Synopsis          A-C 3.         Memorandum of Petition        4.         Vakalatnama   5.         Memorandum of Registered Address            6.         List of documents       7.         EXHIBIT- “A”:- A true Copy of Marriage Certificate  8.         EXHIBIT- “B” Copy of the order dated 28.7.2021 of the High Court of Bombay exploring...

Continue reading

Doctrine of locus poenintentae does not empower a court to alter a judgment pronounced in the open court except with notice to the parties and affording them an opportunity to be heard. Read the Review in Rambo Fashions case.

Rambo Fashions Limited                                       … Review Petitioner (Orig. Petitioner)                         Versus Board of Directors, State Bank of India and ors.                     … Respondents (Orig. Respondents) SYNOPSIS The Review Petitioner is constrained to seek a review of the judgment dated 9.9.2021 passed in the above Writ Petition, for the said judgment which was uploaded in the website of the Registry of the Bombay High Court rendered by the division bench headed by the Hon'ble Chief is one rendered void ab initio, still born, one which never existed in the eye of law.Because what has been authenticated and uploaded is different from the one which was...

Continue reading

Reply by our President, Mr. Mathews Nedumpara to the letter of a Former Union Minister and currently a Member of Parliament on Judicial Reforms.

Sir, Thank you so much for your kind letter and the good wishes for my humble effort. Judicial reform is nearly impossible without the actual participation and initiative of the members of Parliament. The perception of the general public is that most of our political leaders are corrupt or incompetent. I certainly do not subscribe to that view. I have been campaigning that to demonize the political executive and political leaders is doing great disservice to the idea of democracy. The decision of the Parliament, as the great philosopher, Sir Thomas Smith, has said in the 16th century, is the decision...

Continue reading

VIDEO-RECORDING OF PROCEEDINGS OF COURTS AND TRIBUNALS – A PANACEA FOR THE ILLS WHICH INDIAN JUDICIARY FACES TODAY.

What prompts me to pen these few lines is a query from one of the few law students who started interning with me recently.  The query was, what is the inspiration for me to initiate the campaign titled National Lawyers’ Campaign for Judicial Transparency and Reforms and the video-recording of proceedings of all Courts and Tribunals in the country as its prime objective. 1. I had no difficulty to answer the query because of the injustice which I personally had to undergo, for, the Judges enjoy absolute immunity in the discharge of their official function and for all practical purposes the...

Continue reading

Judges’ disease

09.01.2022 Judges' disease There can be no two opinion that the bar and the bench are the two sides of the same coin and should respect each other and maintain a cordial and healthy relationship. However, as legendary Justice Krishna Iyer has lamented a not so minority among the judges become afflicted of " judges disease " and treat litigants and lawyers badly. The hapless lawyer and the litigant, the victim of arrogance, pomposity and irritability of the judges if had reacted out of sense of hurt, being humiliated and ill treated publically is threatened with contempt. The only option open to...

Continue reading

Suo motu PILs and judicial activism is undemocratic and a threat to the independence of judiciary

Mathews J NedumparaPresident, NLC98205 354287.11.2021 Nobody can be an actor (suitor) and a judex (judge) at the same time is a fundamental principle of law. A court can make an exception to that to correct grave errors at its hands, suo motu, acting on itself. Judges are free citizens and they are free to do whatever is not prohibited by law is not a correct perception. The office they occupy is sacrosanct and their conduct should be exemplary. They should command respect by the quality of their judgements, erudition, their independence, fairness and impartiality. It is forbidden for a judge to...

Continue reading

Judicial Accountability Act – A must for protection from wilful denial of justice, impropriety and corruption

01.01.2022. There are innumerable instances in India, nay, even in US, UK and other advanced countries, of innocents being convicted and sentenced to death and their innocence being brought to the public domain after they have been executed or have undergone the punishment. In the western countries, such conviction of innocent men and women is the result of the fallibilty of the justice delivery system manned by even the best. Adoption of modern technology in the detection of crime and prosecution, including video recording of court proceedings is certain to reduce innocent people being convicted because of human error to the...

Continue reading

If the king (sovereign) is below God and the law, the judges and the depositories of the judicial power of the sovereign are not above God and law

a

Hon'ble Mr. Justice Dipankar Datta,Chief justice,High Court of Judicature at Bombay. May it please your Lordship, I logged in to the Chief Justice's Court even before 11 am this morning and sat all throughout, waiting to be admitted, inspite of the unbearable pain due to slipped disc. I send a screenshot via whatsapp to Shri Chandwani, Prothonotory, and Shri Nikumb, your lordship’s associate, pointing out that I have not been admitted and requesting them to admit me, since my case, Sr. No. 29, a petition instituted by a designated covid hospital seeking immediate oxygen supply. I do not wish to attribute any...

Continue reading

Wilful denial of justice by Shri Komalsing Rajput, Metropolitan Magistrate, Bandra, Mumbai, to a widow thrown out of her home – Complaint- reg.

Mrs. Sabina Lakdawalaw/o late Mr. Yusuf M. LakdawalaFlat 14,15 Sunflower BuildingCarter Rd, Bandra West, Mumbai,Maharashtra 400050Communication may be addressed to my lawyer,Adv. Maria Nedumpara, at12F , A wing, Harbour Heights,Narayan A Sawant Rd, Azad Nagar,Colaba, Mumbai,Maharashtra- 4000059820910396/9820535428 30 December, 2021 To,1) Hon’ble Mr. Justice Dipankar DattaChief Justice of the High Court of Bombay Also to,All the judges of the High Court of Bombay May it please your Lordship/Ladyship, Sub: Wilful denial of justice by Shri Komalsing Rajput, Metropolitan Magistrate, Bandra, Mumbai, to a widow thrown out of her home – Complaint- reg. 1. I am the wife of late Mr. Yusuf Lakdawala who died on 9.9.2021...

Continue reading

Disclaimer:


The Bar Council of India does not permit advertisement or solicitation by advocates in any form or manner. By accessing this website you acknowledge and confirm that you are seeking information relating to our firm of your own accord and that there has been no form of solicitation or advertisement by us. The contents of this website is intended purely for educational and informational purposes and should not be construed as soliciting, advertisement or as legal advice.


The contents of this website are the intellectual property of Nedumpara & Nedumpara. No material on this site may be copied, reproduced, republished, uploaded, posted, transmitted or distributed in any way without the prior written permission of Nedumpara & Nedumpara.