Nedumpara

Should the lawyer who told the Chief Justice, “You don’t deserve to be in the chair,” be punished for contempt, or not?Whatever I write, I write with a great amount of pain and anguish. I am someone who has spent four and a half decades in the legal profession. Every passing day brings great pain as I see how things have degraded.Yesterday, an incident happened where a lawyer used abusive words against the Chief Justice, Chief Justice Surya Kant. He said, “You don’t deserve to be in the chair.”What he said is certainly not acceptable, and no Chief Justice can tolerate it. So, the SCBA has, I believe, filed a contempt of court case against the lawyer. This lawyer, I believe, may be convicted for contempt, or Justice Surya Kant may take a lenient view, as Justice Gavai did.The question is: can we contain the anger and frustration of litigants and lawyers through contempt of court proceedings? And how many contempt of court proceedings will you initiate?Now, see, the judges fail to realize that the moment you enter the domain of the executive—the moment you started governing the country through PILs, acting in substitution of the executive and the legislature—you usurped their power. Then you became not a democracy, but a “judge-ocracy.” People have even coined a new term: “milordocracy.”Judges cannot solve all the problems. There is an elected executive. They may be a total failure, but you cannot substitute them. And if you try to substitute them, then the people will treat you like they treat politicians. They abuse the Prime Minister, and that freedom ought to be there in a democracy.The common man may not use the most appropriate language. He may not be balanced in his approach. That is a liberty you have to concede to the common people. They have the right to protest. Protests sometimes lead to violence as well.Somebody in the political arena is seasoned to it, or ought to be mentally prepared for it. You cannot enjoy power while remaining in glass houses; people will throw stones at you. Confining yourselves to your legitimate domain of the adjudication of lis is the answer to the increasing abuse you face. I respect the institution; judges come and go. No democracy and no society can survive without a judiciary. So, what the judges ought to realize is that they cannot govern the country. People may come to you bringing PILs asking you to remove the Prime Minister, remove the Election Commissioner, or enact laws. But simply put, that is not your job.I only pray to the Almighty that the judges do not fall prey to the folly and great damage to the country that a few lawyers commit by bringing PILs asking the court to decide and govern everything under the sun.